Does God choose sides in war?

 


Does God choose sides in war?

This image of a soldier before the Battle of Kursk in 1943 intrigues me.  

I have always wondered whether his faith and clasping his cross before the battle, provided him any comfort.

Reading the letters of soldiers, who fought in Somme Battle in 1916, provides glimpses into their inner-most thoughts about God. 

Many soldiers, such as Sergeant Philip Browne, appealed to God prior to battles. He wrote, ‘Please god we will come through safe.’ 

Philip was killed that day, his body never recovered. 

Prior to an attack, Captain Charles Dawkins wrote, ‘God, I hope it’s a success and I come through all right,’ while his comrade, Lieutenant Len Wadsley wrote, ‘I leave myself in the hands of the Almighty and trust him absolutely.’ 

Both men died in the failed attack. 

Many soldiers who survived the Somme could not fathom how they got through unscathed.  Some attributed their luck to God’s providence. ‘The Lord seems to especially look after us doesn’t he,’ wrote Allan Leane. ‘It is remarkable the luck we have, let’s hope it lasts.’

It didn’t; Leane died at Bullecourt in 1917. 

Alfred Stewart thanked God for bringing him through the Somme alive. In return, he promised to devote the rest of his life to God’s work. 

The rest of his life was short; he was killed in September 1917.

These incidents have you wondering whether God, in fact, perhaps favoured ‘the enemy’. 

This account of a soldier clearing trenches of dead Germans suggests not. He asked his officer what the inscription on the Germans’ belt buckles said. The officer roughly translated, ‘God with us for King and Fatherland.’

‘Well, God doesn’t seem to have done much for these blokes,’ the soldier replied.

Perhaps God had no favourites. 

Or perhaps, as Napoleon noted: ‘God favoured the side with the best artillery.’ 

My recently released novel, ‘Night in Passchendaele’ out now

📚 Sources & References

Soldiers’ letters from the Battle of the Somme (1916), Imperial War Museums collections

Personal correspondence of British WWI soldiers, including Philip Browne, Charles Dawkins, and Len Wadsley

Eyewitness trench accounts published in postwar memoirs and regimental histories

German military belt buckle inscription: “Gott mit uns” (God with us), standard issue in both World Wars

Napoleon Bonaparte, attributed quotation on warfare and artillery

Secondary historical analyses on religion and belief among soldiers in wartime



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Walking Through the Dead: A Visit to Nanjing and the Reality of the 1937 Massacre

Image
  WARNING: GRAPHIC HISTORY The following article discusses rape, mass murder, and extreme wartime violence. Reader discretion is strongly advised. Walking Through the Dead: A Visit to Nanjing and the Reality of the 1937 Massacre After entering a large museum in one of the world’s oldest cities Nanking, now called Nanjing my 18-year-old daughter Sophia and I stepped onto a glass walkway suspended above the earth. Beneath our feet lay an ancient path, preserved ten feet below ground. Soft lights illuminated the soil while the surrounding hall remained dark, silent, and heavy. On the black walls to our right hung photographs taken in December 1937. They were not artistic recreations. They were real images captured by Imperial Japanese Army soldiers themselves. Babies murdered. Prisoners beheaded. Bodies piled along the banks of the Yangtze River. Heads severed and displayed as trophies. This was not rumor. This was documentation. The photographs formed a brutal record of what h...
Read more

The Truth Behind 'Russian Popeye' story

Image
  Russian popeye Stop Calling the “Russian Popeye” a Bodybuilder: This Is Not Bodybuilding One of the biggest problems in today’s fitness world is misinformation. Anyone who lifts weights or goes to the gym is quickly labeled a bodybuilder . This careless use of words has caused serious confusion and sometimes fear about what bodybuilding truly is. Let’s be clear: weight training does not automatically make someone a bodybuilder . Weight training is simply a tool. Athletes use it to improve speed, strength, and performance. Everyday people use it to stay fit and healthy. Bodybuilders use it to build muscle for structured competition, under strict rules and standards. So even if someone has a muscular body, if they are not training and competing in bodybuilding events, they are not bodybuilders. This misunderstanding has fueled the viral story of the man often called the “Russian Popeye.” Big Arms Alone Do Not Define Bodybuilding The media widely described this ma...
Read more

He Was Only 17 When He Chose to Save Others

Image
  In 2023, the United States Navy commissioned USS Jack H. Lucas , an Arleigh Burke–class destroyer. The ship carries the name of a Marine whose courage came before fear—a boy who became a legend before he became an adult. Jacklyn “Jack” Lucas was only 17 years old when he landed on Iwo Jima in February 1945 . He was not supposed to be there. He was underage. But war had already changed the rules of his life. After the attack on Pearl Harbor, Lucas became consumed with one thought: he had to fight . He forged his mother’s signature, lied about his age, and joined the U.S. Marine Corps at just 14 years old . He was young, stubborn, and determined. When assigned a rear job, he refused to accept it. Combat was where he believed he belonged. So he did the unthinkable he stowed away on a ship headed for war . Two days after landing on Iwo Jima, reality arrived without warning. Lucas and his fire team were suddenly ambushed by enemy soldiers. His rifle jammed. There was no tim...
Read more

When I Held My Uncle’s Hand After Death: What I Saw Changed How I Understand Life and God

Image
  When I Held My Uncle’s Hand After Death: What I Saw Changed How I Understand Life and God Death is something we all know will happen, yet nothing truly prepares you for the moment it arrives right in front of your eyes. I never imagined that one of the most unforgettable experiences of my life would happen in a quiet hospital room, holding my uncle’s hand, long after the doctors had said he was gone. When the machines were finally disconnected and the doctors gently said the words, “He’s dead,” everything felt unreal. I did not cry immediately. I did not scream. I simply stayed there. I kept holding his hand. His fingers were still wrapped around mine, as if he did not want to let go. What shocked me most was that his hand was still warm. Not the warmth of memory or imagination, but real warmth. His body did not look lifeless. He looked peaceful, calm, like someone taking a deep rest after a long, exhausting journey. For several minutes—maybe three or four—I stayed there wat...
Read more

Sgt. Monica Lin Brown: An 18-Year-Old Medic Who Redefined Courage in Afghanistan

Image
  At just 18 years old, Sgt. Monica Lin Brown ran toward gunfire so others could live. In April 2007, while serving as a U.S. Army combat medic with the 782nd Brigade Support Battalion, 82nd Airborne Division , Monica Lin Brown was deployed to Afghanistan. During a patrol in the Jani Khel District , her unit was struck by an improvised explosive device (IED), followed by intense enemy small-arms fire and mortar attacks. As soldiers fell wounded around her, Brown did what few could she repeatedly sprinted through active enemy fire and exploding mortars to reach the injured. Ignoring her own safety, she administered emergency medical care while shielding wounded soldiers with her own body , preventing further casualties and saving multiple lives. Her actions reflected not only exceptional bravery, but also the highest standards of military service, discipline, and selflessness. A Historic Silver Star Recipient For her extraordinary heroism in combat, Sgt. Monica Lin Brown was a...
Read more

The Capture of Captain Rosinski: Brutality and Moral Collapse During the Soviet Westward Offensive

Image
WARNING: GRAPHIC HISTORY This article discusses extreme violence and torture during wartime. Reader discretion is strongly advised. The Capture of Captain Rosinski: Brutality and Moral Collapse During the Soviet Westward Offensive In 1918, while much of Europe celebrated the end of World War I, violence continued unabated in Eastern Europe. One haunting image from Belarus captures the fate of a Russian officer named Captain Rosinski , whose death became a chilling symbol of how quickly ideology, chaos, and power can strip away humanity. Rosinski was captured by Bolshevik forces during the violent upheavals that followed the collapse of imperial authority in the region. According to contemporary accounts, he was subjected to prolonged torture after refusing to provide information. What followed was not interrogation it was cruelty for its own sake. Eyewitnesses described a killing intended not only to end a life, but to humiliate and terrorize. The brutality shocked even those acc...
Read more

Women, Medicine, and the Inquisition: What History Really Shows

Image
  Women, Medicine, and the Inquisition: What History Really Shows For centuries, a powerful story has circulated: that the Inquisition hunted down women healers, burned all female doctors, and wiped out ancient sacred knowledge held only by women. This story carries deep pain and parts of it are rooted in real historical suffering. But much of it has also been simplified, exaggerated, or mixed with myth . To understand what truly happened, we must separate documented history from later symbolism . The truth is less mystical but no less tragic. Women and Medicine Before the Inquisition In medieval Europe, women were deeply involved in healthcare , especially at the community level. Women served as midwives , herbal healers, caregivers, and nurses. They treated wounds, childbirth complications, fevers, and everyday illnesses. Much medical knowledge was passed orally , from mother to daughter. However, it is not accurate to say women dominated all branches of medicine. Un...
Read more

Slavery in Ancient Rome: How the System Worked and Shaped Roman Society

Image
Slavery was a central part of life in ancient Rome. It shaped the economy, social structure, and everyday living across the Roman world. Enslaved people worked in almost every area of Roman society, from hard labor to highly skilled professions. Many slaves did difficult and dangerous work in farms, mines, and mills. These workers had little chance of improving their lives or gaining freedom. Others, however, were skilled or educated. These slaves worked as artisans, cooks, household servants, entertainers, teachers, doctors, accountants, librarians, and even business managers. Skilled slaves often lived better lives and had a real hope of earning their freedom. One unique feature of Roman slavery was manumission —the legal process through which slaves could be freed. Freed slaves, known as freedpersons , could become Roman citizens under certain conditions. Over time, many freedpersons became influential members of Roman society. In practice, slaves, freed people, and free workers...
Read more

He was only 31 years old when his journey ended on the steep, unforgiving ridges of New Guinea.

Image
  He was only 31 years old when his journey ended on the steep, unforgiving ridges of New Guinea . Private Francis Morris Heinz was not remembered for loud heroics or dramatic speeches. He was known for something quieter and rarer—steady courage. Fellow soldiers described him as dependable, calm, and strong in spirit, the kind of man others felt safer marching beside. In one haunting wartime photograph, Francis is seen walking toward the front line alongside his closest friend. Boots pressed into narrow jungle paths, rifles slung, faces set with determination. It was an ordinary moment during an extraordinary war—unremarkable at the time, yet destined to become the last visual record of his life. Just twelve days later , tragedy struck. While navigating the dangerous terrain of New Guinea’s mountainous jungle, Private Heinz suffered a fatal fall. In a campaign where nature itself was often deadlier than enemy fire, the jungle claimed another life. He never made it home. Yet...
Read more

The Reunion of Terry Gurrola and Her Daughter (2007): A Quiet Image That Revealed the True Cost of War

Image
A silent moment in 2007: Army medic Terry Gurrola returns home from Iraq as her daughter clings to her, afraid to let go. Some photographs don’t shout. They don’t show explosions, blood, or destruction. Yet they stay with you far longer than any battlefield image ever could. One of those photographs was taken in 2007- the moment Terry Gurrola , a U.S. Army medic, returned home after a seven-month deployment near Ramadi, Iraq , one of the most dangerous regions of the war. There were no grand speeches. No waving flags in the frame. Just a mother standing still… and a child holding on for dear life. A Child Who Refused to Let Go When Terry finally reunited with her daughter, the little girl did something unexpected. She didn’t run into her arms screaming. She didn’t smile for the camera. Instead, she wrapped her arms tightly around her mother’s leg . She pressed her face against the uniform. She clung—silent, unmoving, desperate—as if letting go might make her mother disappe...
Read more